I didn't really think I'd like this wet bag, it wasn't my first choice. But it works great! I like the fact that I can just rinse it off under some running water to get the pee smell out of it and then keep using it. I really would prefer that it had a zipper to really close it up and keep the smell away, but it's not horrible by any means. It DOES cinch up pretty tightly. It holds up better than